How to choose an engagement ring – 5 key steps

jodiegearingAdvice2 Comments

So you have decided to propose! Congratulations! But how do you go about choosing an engagement ring? It is one of life’s most meaningful and romantic purchases that no one wants to get wrong. The job of selecting a piece of jewellery you hope your significant other will wear for the rest of their life can understandably cause a fair amount of stress. So here’s my guide of five key steps you can take to ease you through the process and relieve some of those pre-proposal jitters.

1. Work out her style

The best place to start is to be observant – take a look both at the jewellery they wear on a day-to-day basis and their special occasion pieces. Are there any common themes in terms of style, colour, and scale? The sort of things you should look for include:

Common themes

Does she have a recurring style across multiple key pieces she loves to wear? For example, does she have lots of classic and vintage style jewellery? Perhaps she has really quirky taste in jewellery or maybe she goes for streamlined and sleek contemporary styles. Try to find a common theme amongst her most loved pieces and this will get you in the right ballpark in terms of design. Take a photo of some her favourite pieces to bring along to a design consultation.

Jonty knew Connie wanted a sapphire and he had observed at common theme of white metal and hammered texture in her usual jewellery, which we used as a starting point for her engagement ring design.

Metal colour

Is there a predominance of one metal colour? Try to notice if she wears more silver, gold or rose gold-toned jewellery as this will help with the metal choice for an engagement ring.


If you notice there is a lot of colour in their jewellery, is there an obvious favourite? When it comes to designing an engagement ring, I would suggest you try and find out whether your other half prefers white diamonds (or similar ‘clear’ stones) or whether they would like the idea of some colour in their engagement ring. My customers usually know if their other half wants a coloured stone in their engagement ring because they will have brought it up and been specific about a type of stone. This may be that they want a sapphire, or they want their birthstone, like Emily told James before he came to me to design their ring (below).

Emily’s ruby engagement ring was designed by James as a surprise. He knew that she wanted her birthstone – ruby – as the centrepiece for her engagement ring.

Something to consider is that even if they wear bright and bold dress jewellery, this doesn’t always correlate to wanting a coloured engagement ring. Often people enjoy wearing colour in their dress jewellery because they can mix it up to match their outfit or mood that day, but want to keep their engagement ring more neutral.

If it has never come up in conversation, you might want to get some close friends or family involved to see if your partner has revealed a preference to them – but be wary of too many cooks! If you’re unsure and your partner has not expressed a deep desire for anything other than a diamond, I would suggest you play it safe and opt for diamonds. Practically speaking, diamonds are the toughest gemstone out there, measuring 10 on the Mohs scale. Sapphires closely follow at 9 and so these are my top choices for engagement rings as you want them to stand the test of time. Moissanite is another fantastic choice if your partner loves sparkle and wants a big rock, but the budget doesn’t stretch to £10k+ – they are also a great choice if she is not bothered by the cachet of diamonds and is interested in sustainability and ethical sourcing as a they are lab made.

Dave opted for a classic diamond in this surprise engagement ring, but wanted a splash of colour so opted for subtle pink sapphires in the shoulders as a nod to her favourite colour.


Lastly, take a look at the scale of her jewellery. Does she wear jewellery with chunky beads, large gemstones or big metal pieces, or does she prefer smaller and more delicate pieces? This will help decide how wide the band should be and what size stones you could choose.

TOP TIP: Other than her jewellery, her taste in watches can be a big clue to the sort of style she might want for an engagement ring, as after all a watch is usually something you wear every day.

The answers to these questions above will give you a great starting point when choosing or designing a ring. Get these key design choices right, and you’ll demonstrate that you’ve noticed and understood her style, which will only add to the romance of the proposal moment.

2. Consider her job and lifestyle.

If your other half has a really hands-on job or has active hobbies and interests, this might influence some of your design decisions. If your loved one works with her hands, you might need to steer clear of really delicate claw settings or very pointed shaped stones which could more easily catch or chip. It can also influence your choice of metal for the ring. No precious metal is indestructible and it is always best practice to take a ring off for any activities which may damage it or where the ring could cause potential for injury, however, a charmingly clumsy lady might find a platinum ring better suited than a gold ring as it is the most durable of the precious metals.

You may decide that the ring would need to be removed for her work or hobbies anyway, so this may not be a big deal, but it is worth thinking about. A thin band and tiny claw setting may not work for all ladies, but if she likes getting her nails done and does not have a physical job, it might suit her perfectly.

Lia’s super delicate ring isn’t for everyone – someone with a very hands on job might want a bezel setting or wider band

3. Budget

There are all sorts of ideas of tradition regarding how much to spend on an engagement ring – 1 or 3 months salary are common figures I have heard being bandied around. But the truth of it is that you should spend what you are comfortable and able to pay. You should never get yourself into financial difficulty for a piece of jewellery but equally, this is a gift that should probably hurt a bit. What this figure is will be different for everybody and there is no right or wrong answer. A quick browse on a jeweller’s website or in their window will give you an idea of the figures involved but of course your choice of stones, metal and complexity of design will impact the cost. I feel it is best to be upfront with your budget from the start because a good designer will work to that figure and not suggest designs outside of your means.

4. Finding out her ring size

This can be a tricky one if you want to keep the element of surprise. If you are unsure, show your jeweller a photo of your partner and find out their clothing size and rough height as these can be good indicators to help choose a ring size. It’s not an exact science and preference on how tight or loose a ring fits is very personal. Err on the side of caution and go larger rather than smaller so you can guarantee the ring will go over the knuckle in the moment of the proposal. The vast majority of rings can be resized so try not to worry about this too much.

5. Trendy or Classic styles

A basic understanding of the major trends in engagement ring jewellery and what the classic shapes look like can help you find a favourite that you think your future Mrs will like.


A solitaire ring is the classic single stone ring. A simple and classic solitaire will have one central stone which is the main focus of the design.

Emily’s radiant cut diamond engagement ring has talon shaped claws that blend into the facets of the diamond.

Solitaire with shoulder detail

You might like the idea of a solitaire but want something extra to make it unique to your partner. Something like diamonds or a coloured gemstone in the shoulders can add something special to your design.

Tom designed this oval diamond engagement ring with diamonds in the shoulders for Jordan


A triology ring is another classic style with very romantic symbolism. These rings have three main central stones that are the key focus of the design and these represent your past, present and future as a couple. The stones can all be diamonds, or you could choose a mixture of colours and stones.

Art Deco inspired trilogy with an Asscher cut diamond with baguette cut emeralds either side


A common design style I get requests for are twist designs. These give a modern and slightly quirky feel as the band wraps around the central stone. Something to bear in mind with these designs is that you will need a fitted wedding ring that will need to be specially made to work with the engagement ring. These can make beautiful and tactile wedding jewellery sets that look beautiful on the finger.

Rebecca’s vintage twist engagement that we made a bespoke fitted wedding ring for


The Halo style is without a doubt the most fashionable engagement ring style of the moment. It is not a trend that is going anywhere fast, as it has been popular for some time now, so is not a fleeting fad. A halo design is when a central stone is surrounded by a gem-set metal plate, usually diamonds. These additional diamonds give an extra bit of sparkle and help to scale up the visual size of the central stone if your lady likes large rocks. Large diamonds can get very pricey, so a halo design around a slightly smaller stone can be a good way to balance the budget and desire for sparkle. They also have a bit of a vintage vibe to them as a modern take on a cluster style.

Gareth designed this pear shaped halo engagement ring for Ellie

Halo style rings can be made in a whole range of shapes – round, cushion, pear or emerald just as a few examples. Halo designs usually allow for straight wedding rings to fit snuggly beside them, which makes wedding ring shopping nice and easy.

This halo style engagement ring mixes round diamonds in the halo and shoulders, along with a sleek emerald cut diamond in the centre.


Cluster rings are the traditional version of a halo ring and is a design style that is here to stay. The sale of cluster rings shot up when Kate Middleton was given Princess Diana’s cluster style engagement ring.

Danielle’s cluster style engagement ring that we made a bespoke fitted wedding ring for is clearly inspired by Princess Diana/Kathryn Middleton’s engagement ring

Clusters are similar to halos in that the central stone is surrounded by more stones (usually diamonds) but they are individually set rather than grain set into a metal plate. The surrounding stones tend to be bigger than those found in a halo ring.

A natural pink cushion shaped diamond in a cluster style engagement ring surrounded by brilliant cut white diamonds.

So there you have it – hopefully this guide has helped focus your thoughts on how to go about picking the perfect engagement ring. Once you’ve done your research on what you think your other half would like using the ideas above, go on a browsing mission, armed with your new found knowledge of engagement ring terminology. Take a look at my gallery of previous commissions for some ideas and take a look at Pinterest once you’ve got an idea of what you’re after, for example, a trilogy ring.

If you’d like to have your perfect ring made from scratch – a unique ring for your one and only – I’d love to hear from you and help you piece together the perfect engagement ring.

2 Comments on “How to choose an engagement ring – 5 key steps”

  1. It helped that you mentioned it’s more beneficial to mention your budget to your ring designer so they can figure out what would be best to use that won’t exceed the costs. My partner and I are getting married next year, so we’re looking into custom wedding rings that are pleasing to the eye but also fit our budget. We’ll have to get in touch with a trusted jeweler that can help design our wedding rings for us.

    1. Hi Anna,
      Really glad my article helped and gave you some tips! Let me know if you would like to chat about your wedding rings – I would be happy to help.
      Best wishes,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *